Secrets, snowstorms and a killer who’s definitely one of us.
Looking for something to fill the nights before the next series in the New Year? The Traitors works because it taps into one of fiction’s oldest tricks: put a group of people somewhere they can’t leave, tell them one of them is lying, and watch the paranoia set in. Crime writers have been playing that game for nearly a century, from snowed-in Highland lodges to a school detention that goes very wrong. These three do it best.
1The Hunting Party by Lucy Foley
The closest you’ll get to the castle without an invite. Every New Year, a group of old university friends goes away together, and this year it’s a remote estate in the Scottish Highlands. When a blizzard cuts them off, one of them turns up dead. The story jumps between the guests and the staff, and every one of them is hiding something. Claudia would have the lot of them at the round table by the second night. Short chapters and constant cliffhangers make it ideal if you’ve fallen out of the reading habit.
2And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
This is where it all started. Ten strangers are invited to a grand house on an island off the Devon coast. Over dinner, a recorded voice accuses each of them of murder. Then, one by one, they start to die… Picture the breakfast reveal, only nobody gets to go home. It’s the best-selling crime novel of all time, and at around 250 pages it’s the perfect first Christie. If you’d like to watch it too, the BBC’s 2015 adaptation stars Aidan Turner, Charles Dance and Sam Neill, and it was the first screen version brave enough to keep Christie’s original ending. Fun fact: it was a big inspiration for Lucy Foley’s The Hunting Party.
3One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus
The easiest pick of the three, and possibly the most addictive. Five students walk into detention at Bayview High, and only four walk out. Simon, the outcast behind the school’s notorious gossip app, collapses and dies, and it turns out he was about to post secrets about every one of them. Four suspects, four secrets and nobody you can quite trust: very round table. Written for teens but loved by plenty of adults, it’s a quick read and it was also turned into a two-season TV series, which you can buy on Apple TV or Amazon in the UK.


